­­­­­
Forwarded
by
Vivian
Prunier/
DC/
USEPA/
US
on
08/
13/
2003
11:
17
AM
­­­­­

Vivian
Prunier
08/
07/
2003
12:
43
PM
To:
Kimberly
Smith/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA
cc:
Subject:
Docket
for
PPDC
Registra
Review
Workgroup
­­
OPP­
2003­
0252
­­­­­
Forwarded
by
Vivian
Prunier/
DC/
USEPA/
US
on
08/
07/
2003
12:
43
PM
­­­­­

Margie
Fehrenbach
07/
10/
2003
02:
09
PM
To:
Britt@
cetos.
org,
cbaker@
gowanco.
com,
cwbrickey@
aol.
com,
pbright@
abcbirds.
org,
screscenzi@
steptoe.
com,
lelworth@
agcenter.
org,
ccqc1946@
pacbell.
net,
Ted.
Head@
us.
nufarm.
com,
Skellner@
cpsa.
org,
glibman@
att.
net,
lori@
yurok.
c
therese.
murtaugh@
usda.
gov,
eolson@
nrdc.
org,
perreault.
peg@
epa.
gov,
pquinn@
theaccordgroup.
com,
rosenberg@
pestworld.
org,
rutzs@
doacs.
state.
fl
troys@
peta.
org,
julie.
spagnoli.
b@
bayer.
com,
nefcon@
aol.
com,
warren@
cpda.
jvroom@
croplifeamerica.
org,
wichterman@
lcmcd.
org
cc:
J­
Amador@
TAMU.
edu,
Steve.
Balling@
delmonte.
com,
Phil@
AGR.
State.
VT.
US,
lori@
minorcrops.
org,
dan@
ffva.
com,
CWBrickey@
aol.
com,
beth.
carroll@
syngenta.
com,
clarkc@
doacs.
state.
fl.
us,
lelworth@
agcenter.
org,
goldad@
consumer.
org,
bgoldburg@
environmentaldefense.
org,
kthayer@
ewg.
org,
djg2@
cdc.
gov,
lori@
yurok.
com,
wkh1@
psu.
edu,
holm@
aesop.
rutgers.
edu,
ajames@
pestfacts
allen.
jennings@
usda.
gov,
mmk2@
cdc.
gov,
skellner@
cspa.
org,
nlewis2@
unl.
e
glibman@
att.
net,
alan@
petnet.
buffalo.
edu,
rich.
liroff@
wwfus.
org,
William.
McCormick@
Clorox.
com,
enicholson@
ufwmail.
com,
eolson@
nrdc.
org
pquinn@
theaccordgroup.
com,
rosenberg@
pestworld.
org,
brutala@
unch.
unc.
ed
sauers.
lj@
pg.
com,
troys@
peta.
org,
has_
shah@
americanchemistry.
com,
julie.
spagnoli.
b@
bayer.
com,
clough.
kerry@
epa.
gov,
warren@
cpda.
com,
Blacco@
ix.
netcom.
com,
ttroxell@
cfsan.
fda.
gov,
jvickery@
mcg.
net,
jvroom@
croplifeamerica.
org,
Kugelzur@
migrantclinician.
org,
cbaker@
gowanco.
com,
ccqc1946@
pacbell.
net,
cliff@
lodiwine.
com,
cwbrickey@
aol.
com,
dan@
ffva.
com,
edsnets@
tvutel.
com,
eortman@
reeusda.
eolson@
nrdc.
org,
ephi@
manainc.
com,
goldad@
consumer.
org,
jamador
tamu.
edu,
janis.
mcfarland@
syngenta.
com,
apolansky@
kda.
state.
ks.
jvroom@
croplifeamerica.
org,
llove78@
aol.
com,
lori@
minorcrops.
org,
markm@
fb.
org,
mmiller@
oehha.
ca.
gov,
nfoster@
usapple.
org,
nefcon@
aol.
com
phelliker@
cdpr.
ca.
gov,
rjjackson@
cdc.
gov,
rkiefer@
cspa.
org,
robhedberg@
erols.
com,
rosenberg@
pestworld.
org,
rutzs@
doacs.
state.
fl.
us,
sarah.
lynch@
wwfus.
org,
sdavis@
nclr.
org,
steve.
balling@
delmonte.
com,
terry.
troxell@
cfsan.
fda.
gov,
Whalon@
pilot.
msu.
edu,
wichterman@
lcmcd.
org,
jwzellers@
aol.
com,
kwzell@
sssnet.
com,
boddisb@
em.
agr.
ca,
Claire_
franklin@
sc.
gc.
ca,
jsass@
nrdc.
org,
csantos@
mail.
ssa.
gob.
mx,
markm@
fb.
org,
Rodman.
joanne@
epa.
gov,
clough.
kerry@
epa.
gov,
rywang@
cdc.
gov,
Tslaton@
cdc.
gov,
Philip
Ross/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Douglas
Parsons/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Jay
Ellenberger/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Vivian
Prunier/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Luis
Suguiyama/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Bruce
Sidwell/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Betty
Shackleford/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Richar
Dumas/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Richard
Keigwin/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Kate
Bouve/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA,
Teresa
Downs/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA
Subject:
Registration
Review
Work
Group
Meeting
Agenda,
July
16,
2003
To:
Registration
Review
Work
Group
Members
cc:
PPDC
Members
and
CARAT
Members
As
promised,
attached
and
pasted
to
this
email
is
a
copy
of
the
draft
agenda
for
the
July
16,
2003,
meeting
of
the
Registration
Review
Work
Group.
The
meeting
will
be
held
from
9:
00­
5:
00
at
the
Sheraton
Crystal
City,
1800
Jefferson
Davis
Highway,
Arlington,
VA
(
703/
486­
7111).
We
will
have
a
conference
line
available
for
those
Work
Group
members
who
are
unable
to
attend
in
person.
If
you
have
not
already
done
so,
please
let
me
know
if
you
plan
attend
or
if
you
wish
to
participate
by
conference
line.

Also
attached
is
a
summary
of
the
July
2
Registration
Review
Work
Group
Teleconference
Call
and
an
updated
Roster
of
the
Registration
Review
Work
Group
members.

Please
also
note
that
on
July
17­
18,
the
Transition
Work
Group
of
the
Committee
to
Advise
on
Reassessment
and
Transition
(
CARAT)
will
be
meeting
at
the
Hilton
Crystal
City.

Draft
AGENDA
REGISTRATION
REVIEW
WORK
GROUP
MEETING
PESTICIDE
PROGRAM
DIALOGUE
COMMITTEE
Sheraton
Crystal
City
1800
Jefferson
Davis
Highway,
Arlington,
VA
(
703)
486­
7111
(
½
block
from
Crystal
City
Metro
Station)
July
16,
2003
9:
00­
9:
15
Welcome
&
Introductions
by
Work
Group
Co­
Chairs
Jay
Ellenberger,
Actg
Director,
Field
&
External
Affairs
Division
Betty
Shackleford,
Actg
Director,
Special
Review
&
Reregistration
Div
9:
15­
9:
45
Review
Agency
and
Summary
of
July
2
Teleconference
Discussion
and
Feedback
from
Workgroup
Participants
Jay
Ellenberger
9:
45­
10:
30
"
Lessons
Learned"
from
Reregistration
&
Tolerance
Reassessment
Process
 
Discussion
and
Feedback
from
Workgroup
Participants
10:
30­
10:
45
Break
10:
45­
11:
15
Continue
"
Lessons
Learned"
Discussion
11:
15­
12:
00
"
Scope"
of
Registration
Review
Workgroup
 
Further
Discussion
Regarding
What
Chemicals
and
Products
Should
be
Included
in
Registration
Review.
Issues
to
be
discussed
include:
Active
Ingredients,
Inerts,
Technicals,
End­
Use
Products,
Tolerances,
etc.

12:
00­
1:
00
Lunch
1:
00­
2:
30
Issue
1:
Priority
Schedule
or
Order
of
Pesticides
for
Registration
Review
2:
30­
2:
45
Break
2:
45­
3:
45
Continue
Issue
1
Discussion
3:
45­
4:
15
Schedule
for
Teleconference
Calls
and
Next
Steps
4:
15­
4:
45
Public
Comment
4:
45­
5:
00
Meeting
Wrap­
up
5:
00
Meeting
Adjourns
­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­

PPDC
Registration
Review
Workgroup
July
2,
2003
Meeting
#
1
(
Teleconference)­­
Minutes
Participants
:
Cindy
Baker,
Carolyn
Brickey,
Patti
Bright,
Larry
Elworth,
Ted
Head,
Gary
Libman,
Therese
Murtagh,
Peg
Perreault,
Bob
Rosenberg,
Steve
Rutz,
Troy
Seidel,
Julie
Spagnoli,
Roberta
Spitko,
Warren
Stickle,
George
Wichterman,
Margie
Fehrenbach,
Jay
Ellenberger,
Teresa
Downs,
&
Rich
Dumas
Discussion:
The
participants
discussed
the
following
topics
during
the
teleconference:
1.
J.
Ellenberger
provided
background
for
and
purpose
of
the
workgroup
 
goal
to
provide
the
PPDC
with
recommendations
on
the
registration
review
process
at
the
next
full
PPDC
meeting
October
29­
30,
2003.
2.
What
is
the
scope
of
registration
review
for
chemicals
and
products
 
active
ingredients,
inerts,
technicals,
end­
use­
products
and
tolerances?
Statue
refers
to
"
pesticides";
does
this
include
inert
ingredient
chemicals?
(
Although
inerts
are
considered
as
part
of
a
review
of
end­
use­
products,
the
workgroup
could
develop
recommendations
for
whether
to
or
how
to
consider
inerts
in
registration
review.)
3.
The
workgroup's
recommendations
should
include
focus
on
process
efficiencies
for
agency
and
stakeholders
(
registrants
and
other
entities
who
participate
in
registration
review),
lessons
learned
from
current
reregistration
program
and
tolerance
reassessment
program;
a
question
was
raised
whether
the
workgroup
needed
to
know
of
future
funding/
resource
needs
to
help
identify
recommendations.
4.
Given
the
relatively
short
time
period
for
the
workgroup
to
develop
recommendations
for
the
October
PPDC
meeting
and
the
likely
complexity
and
breadth
of
the
registration
review
program
process,
the
workgroup
needs
to
focus
its
attention
and
develop
recommendations
on
a
few
major
process
issues.
These
were
identified
as:
1)
Considerations
for
determining
the
priority
schedule
or
the
order
of
pesticides
for
registration
review;
2)
Considerations
for
level(
s)
of
review
for
different
pesticides
3)
Stakeholder
involvement/
participation
during
the
process
5.
In
the
next
meeting,
the
workgroup
will
decide
how
it
should
organize
itself
to
address
these
issues.

Future
meetings:

°
The
group
intends
to
have
two
face­
to­
face
meetings
 
one
in
July
and
another
in
early
October
prior
to
the
PPDC
meeting.
In
addition,
there
will
be
three
teleconferences
between
the
two
face­
to
face
meetings.

Next
Steps:

°
OPP
will
schedule
the
July
meeting,
possibly
around
the
CARAT
meeting
and
let
all
members
know
ASAP
°
Distribute
minutes
Jay
Ellenberger,
Co­
Chair,
7/
7/
03
Margie
Fehrenbach
Office
of
Pesticide
Programs
(
7501C)
US
Environmental
Protection
Agency
1200
Pennsylvania
Avenue,
NW
Washington,
DC
20460
703/
308­
4775
Phone
703/
308­
4776
Fax
571/
220­
3096
Cell
