Ron Evans/RTP/USEPA/US

05/01/2008 11:32 AM

	

To

"Lee, Amanda I." <Amanda_I._Lee@omb.eop.gov>

cc

"King, Heidi R." <Heidi_R._King@omb.eop.gov>, Kathy
Kaufman/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA"King, Heidi R." <Heidi_R._King@omb.eop.gov>,
Kathy Kaufman/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Tricia Crabtree/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Lydia
Wegman, fann.neal@epa.gov, darryl weatherhead, walton.tom@epa.gov,
simon.nathalie@epa.gov, Brian Heninger

Subject

RE: Updated lead NAAQS benefits chapters









We will incorporate your comment as requested.

"Lee, Amanda I." <Amanda_I._Lee@omb.eop.gov> 

05/01/2008 10:26 AM

	

To

Ron Evans/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Kathy Kaufman/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA

cc

"King, Heidi R." <Heidi_R._King@omb.eop.gov>

Subject

RE: Updated lead NAAQS benefits chapters









Sorry Ron.  I mis-spoke.  You'll find a sentence added to your edits on

p. 16 (Woods and Poole section).  I was attempting to clarify and

cross-reference to ch. 4. 

-----Original Message-----

From: King, Heidi R. 

Sent: Thursday, May 01, 2008 8:36 AM

To: 'Pritchard.Eileen@epamail.epa.gov'; Lee, Amanda I.; Beck, Nancy;

Fraas, Arthur G.

Cc: Crabtree.Tricia@epamail.epa.gov; Joseph-J Dougherty;

Wegman.Lydia@epamail.epa.gov; Henigin.Mary@epamail.epa.gov;

Fann.Neal@epamail.epa.gov; Evans.Ron@epamail.epa.gov;

Rodriguez.Rosalina@epamail.epa.gov; Alan Rush;

Jutras.Nathaniel@epamail.epa.gov; Schillo.Bruce@epamail.epa.gov;

Clark.Mike@epamail.epa.gov; Bertrand.Charlotte@epamail.epa.gov;

'Simon.Nathalie@epamail.epa.gov'

Subject: RE: Updated lead NAAQS benefits chapters

Good morning folks.  Some early-morning comments on a key area for

further work on the Benes Chapter:

In Chapter 5 -- the Benefits Chapter -- 

First, I did not yet find the language in the introduction reflecting

our agreement of last Friday 4/25, requested again in written comments

from OMB in an email Tuesday 4/29.  The Chapter intro (and include the

same or summary language in Exec Summ) should reflect that the benefits

baseline reflects 2005(?) conditions *not 2020 conditions appropriate

for net bene comparison with 2020 baseline used in the Cost chapter* and

will be re-examined and adjusted to reflect continued declines in Blood

Lead Levels (BLL) expected from Lead RRP Rule as well as through

anticipated to continue to reflect declines in BLL across time in the

US.  

Recall OMB had described this as a critical issue for approvability of

the RIA.

The caveat should be carried through to the tables and the numbers to

minimize the potential for these initial draft numbers -- estimated on

an expedited timeline -- are not taken as a best assessment reflective

of 2020 baseline conditions, and in fact are likely to be overestimates.

Please let me know if I've overlooked this language; my apologies if I

have indeed (although my overlooking it suggests that perhaps it could

be amplified somewhat?)

Second, how do we propose to sync the key parameters with the rule on

this production schedule?  

Third, we continue to be concerned that there is not co-equal

presentation of the .9 and .88 RRP slope factor in Exhibit 5-5

Also -- I believe we continue to hope to see a stacked bar in Ch 5 as

requested by Margo last week, where the total bar reflects total

benefits broken out by Pb and PM benefits.

Thanks; I'll continue reading -- please don't hesitate to reach out if I

can help clarify, or if I am missing something --

Grateful for your work on this,

heidi

-----Original Message-----

From: Pritchard.Eileen@epamail.epa.gov

[mailto:Pritchard.Eileen@epamail.epa.gov]

Sent: Thursday, May 01, 2008 4:47 AM

To: King, Heidi R.

Cc: Crabtree.Tricia@epamail.epa.gov; Joseph-J Dougherty;

Wegman.Lydia@epamail.epa.gov; Henigin.Mary@epamail.epa.gov;

Fann.Neal@epamail.epa.gov; Evans.Ron@epamail.epa.gov;

Rodriguez.Rosalina@epamail.epa.gov; Alan Rush;

Jutras.Nathaniel@epamail.epa.gov; Schillo.Bruce@epamail.epa.gov;

Clark.Mike@epamail.epa.gov; Bertrand.Charlotte@epamail.epa.gov

Subject: Updated lead NAAQS benefits chapters

************************

Eileen Pritchard

EPA/OPEI/OPRM

1200 Pennsylvania Ave, NW

Room 3521-C

Mailcode 1804-A

Washington, DC 20460

(202)564-6578

(202)566-0268 - FAX

email:  pritchard.eileen@epa.gov

----- Forwarded by Eileen Pritchard/DC/USEPA/US on 05/01/2008 04:42 AM

-----

                                                                        

             Kathy                                                      

             Kaufman/RTP/USEP                                           

             A/US                                                    To 

                                      Eileen Pritchard/DC/USEPA/US@EPA  

             04/30/2008 04:11                                        cc 

             PM                       Tricia Crabtree/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, 

                                      "Joseph-J Dougherty"              

                                      <Dougherty.Joseph-J@epamail.epa.g 

                                      ov>, Lydia                        

                                      Wegman/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Mary     

                                      Henigin/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Neal     

                                      Fann/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Ron        

                                      Evans/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Rosalina  

                                      Rodriguez/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, "Alan 

                                      Rush" <Rush.alan@epa.gov>         

                                                                Subject 

                                      Fw: Updated lead benefits chapter 

                                                                        

                                                                        

                                                                        

                                                                        

                                                                        

                                                                        

Heidi :  By this email EPA is transmitting revised  Chapters 1 through 7

of the Pb NAAQS RIA, as well as  the Executive Summary, to OMB for

review.   Changes have been made in response to OMB's comments are

highlighted or colored in blue or red.

The chapters are attached below.

Your contact on this RIA is Kathy Kaufman, who can be reached on 919 541

0102.

(See attached file: Ch 5 Benefits Analysis Approach and Results

4-30-08.doc)(See attached file: Pb RIA Exec Summ Draft 4-29-08.doc)(See

attached file: Pb RIA Chapter 1 draft 4-29-08.doc)(See attached file: Pb

RIA Chapter 2 Draft 4-29-08.doc)(See attached file: Pb RIA Chapter 3

Draft 4-29-08.doc)

(See attached file: Pb RIA Chapter 4 Draft 4-29-08.doc)(See attached

file: Pb RIA Chapter 6 Draft 4-29-08.doc)(See attached file: Pb RIA

Chapter 7 Draft 4-29-08.doc)

************************

Eileen Pritchard

EPA/OPEI/OPRM

1200 Pennsylvania Ave, NW

Room 3521-C

Mailcode 1804-A

Washington, DC 20460

(202)564-6578

(202)566-0268 - FAX

email:  pritchard.eileen@epa.gov

[attachment "Ch 5 Benefits Analysis Approach and Results 4-30-08 (2)
(2).doc" deleted by Ron Evans/RTP/USEPA/US] 

