Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US 

03/05/2007 12:45 PM

	

To

rhenders@lrri.org, ellis_cowling@ncsu.edu, crapoj@njc.org,
dcrawfor@email.unc.edu, rich.poirot@state.vt.us, trussell@ce.gatech.edu,
frank.speizer@channing.harvard.edu, jbalmes@itsa.ucsf.edu, jimg@usc.edu,
hgong@ladhs.org, harkemaj@msu.edu, hansonpz@comcast.net,
hopkepk@clarkson.edu, mtkleinm@uci.edu, allan.legge@shaw.ca,
lippmann@env.med.nyu.edu, fjmiller@nc.rr.com,
Maria.T.Morandi@uth.tmc.edu, cgplopper@ucdavis.edu,
sheppard@u.washington.edu, jsu@psu.edu, jim@stat.ubc.ca,
svedal@u.washington.edu, barbz@dri.edu

cc

Subject

Fw: Speaker's List, Panel Member (Poirot, Morandi) and Public (Adams,
Smith, ALA) Comments for Today's (March 5, 2007) CASAC Ozone Review
Panel Teleconference re: EPA's Final Ozone Staff Paper









*** IMPORTANT ***

To:  CASAC Ozone Review Panel Members 

The speaker's list for today's (Monday, March 5, 2007) teleconference
meeting of the CASAC Ozone Review Panel to review the Agency's Final
Ozone Staff Paper is forward below as an Adobe PDF file.  

In addition, the individual review comments of Panel members Rich Poirot
and Maria Morandi on the Final Ozone Staff Paper are forwarded as an MS
Word file and as text, respectively, in their messages to me below. 
Furthermore, the public comments of Drs. Williams C. Adams (UC-Davis)
and Richard L. Smith (UNC), and the American Lung Association (ALA), are
attached below in either Word or PDF.

Finally, as a reminder, to access this teleconference, please call the
following toll-free dial-in number: (866) 299-3188.  Then, when
prompted, enter the following Conference Code (access) number:
202-343-9994, followed by the "pound" sign (#).  Please contact me on my
cell phone (number below) if you experience any difficulties accessing
the teleconference.

I look forward to our teleconference meeting this afternoon.  As always,
please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments.

Best,

Fred

***************************************************

Fred Butterfield

Designated Federal Officer

Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC)

EPA Science Advisory Board (SAB) Staff Office

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Phone: (202) 343-9994

Cell: (703) 915-9799

Fax: (202) 233-0643/0645

E-mail: butterfield.fred@epa.gov

SAB Home page: http://www.epa.gov/sab

----- Forwarded by Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US on 03/05/2007 12:01 PM
-----

Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US 

03/05/2007 11:45 AM

	

To

Allen Lefohn <alefohn@asl-associates.com>, Frank Losey
<f.losey@insightbb.com>, Bryan Brendle <BBrendle@nam.org>, Deborah
Shprentz <dshprentz@hers.com>, Giedrius Ambrozaitis
<gambrozaitis@autoalliance.org>, William C. Adams <wcadams@ucdavis.edu>,
Richard L. Smith <rls@email.unc.edu>, Will Ollison <ollisonw@api.org>,
John Balbus <jbalbus@environmentaldefense.org>, Nick Goldstein
<ngoldstein@artba.org>

cc

Janet Losey <jjlosey@insightbb.com>

Subject

Fw: Speaker's List for Today's (March 5, 2007) CASAC Ozone Review Panel
Teleconference re: EPA's Final Ozone Staff Paper









All,

The list of public speakers for today's (Monday, March 5, 2007)
teleconference meeting of the CASAC Ozone Review Panel to review the
Agency's Final Ozone Staff Paper is attached as an Adobe PDF file.  Per
my previous correspondence, the order of speakers was determined on a
"first-come, first-served" basis unless a speaker asked for a particular
time slot due to a scheduling issue.  I regret not being able to furnish
this to you earlier.

As a reminder, to access this teleconference, please call the following
toll-free dial-in number: (866) 299-3188.  Then, when prompted, enter
the following Conference Code (access) number: 202-343-9994, followed by
the "pound" sign (#).  Please contact me on my cell phone (number below)
if you experience any difficulties accessing the teleconference.

Thanks very much.  Please feel free to contact me if you have any
questions or comments, or call me on my cell phone (number below) if you
have any difficulties accessing the teleconference.  We look forward to
hearing your comments this afternoon.

Therefore, since brevity is the soul of wit,

And tediousness the limbs and outward flourishes,

I will be brief.

~William Shakespeare, Hamlet

Best,

Fred

***************************************************

Fred Butterfield

Designated Federal Officer

Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC)

EPA Science Advisory Board (SAB) Staff Office

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Phone: (202) 343-9994

Cell: (703) 915-9799

Fax: (202) 233-0643/0645

E-mail: butterfield.fred@epa.gov

SAB Home page: http://www.epa.gov/sab

----- Forwarded by Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US on 03/05/2007 12:38 PM
-----

"Poirot, Rich" <Rich.Poirot@state.vt.us> 

03/04/2007 08:43 PM

	

To

ellis cowling <ellis_cowling@ncsu.edu>, Fred
Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Rogene Henderson <rhenders@lrri.org>

cc

richpo@comcast.net

Subject

RE: Comments on Chapter 8 in the Final Staff Paper on Ozone









Rogene, Ellis, Fred,

Here are my comments - late as usual - on chapters 7 & 8 of the final
ozone staff paper.

rich

----- Forwarded by Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US on 03/05/2007 12:40 PM
-----

"Morandi, Maria T" <Maria.T.Morandi@uth.tmc.edu> 

03/04/2007 10:04 PM

	

To

Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

cc

Subject

Ozone Staff Paper









Hi, Fred:

Sorry, but I rpobably will not be able to participate tomorrow. If I
can, I will call and participate part of the time

The current version of the Staff Paper represents a significant
improvement over the first draft. In general, the staff was responsive
to the major concerns of the Panel, foremost among them the
inconsistency between the scientific evidence for health effects of
ozone observed at levels below the current primary standard that are
described in the draft AQDR and summarized in the Staff Paper, and the
recommendation for maintaining the current primary standard.  

I have some concern with the description of the upper bound of the
recommended range for arevised primary as a “…range of somewhat
below 0.080 ppm .to 0.060 ppm..” in multiple areas of Chapter 6. Since
the Staff Paper risk scenarios  include the 0.074, 0.070, and 0.064 as
representative levels of the recommended range  it would strengthen the
recommendation to provide a value for the upper bound of the range (say
0.074) as it is done for the lower bound (0.060 ppm). 

Maria

----- Forwarded by Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US on 03/05/2007 12:41 PM
-----

Richard Smith <rls@email.unc.edu> 

03/04/2007 11:46 AM

	

To

Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

cc

Subject

Re: Approval of Your Request to Offer Public Comments at March 5, 2007
CASAC Ozone Review Panel Teleconference re: EPA's Final Ozone Staff
Paper









Dear Fred, Attached is my comment for the teleconference tomorrow. If
it's 

possible to circulate this to the CASAC members in advance of the
meeting, 

I'd be grateful if you would do that.

Best regards, Richard Smith

----- Forwarded by Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US on 03/05/2007 12:42 PM
-----

"William C. Adams" <wcadams@ucdavis.edu> 

03/04/2007 06:54 PM

	

To

Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

cc

Subject

electronic copy for telecf.









Fred. Attached is an electronic copy of my statement for tomorrow's  

teleconference.  Bill Adams

----- Forwarded by Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US on 03/05/2007 12:43 PM
-----

Deborah Shprentz <dshprentz@hers.com> 

03/05/2007 11:25 AM

	

To

Fred Butterfield/DC/USEPA/US@EPA

cc

Subject

Statement for today's teleconference









Fred,

Attached please find my statement for the 3-5-07 CASAC ozone panel for
distribution to the committee members.  Thank you!

--

Deborah Shprentz

Consultant to the American Lung Association

Phone: 703-437-0959                                        

   Fax:  703-437-6580

   Cell:  703-867-0959

dshprentz@hers.com

  

