APPENDIX
6
Presentation
from
June
17,
2003,
Stakeholder
Meeting
Description
of
June
17,
2003,
Presentation
Maps
Technical
Analysis
Used
to
Develop
Optional
Nonattainment
Boundaries
for
8­
Hour
Ozone
for
the
Greater
Phoenix
Area,
July
2003
1
Overview
of
Technical
Analysis
And
Presentation
Of
8­
Hour
Ozone
Boundary
Options
June
17,
2003
Gary
Neuroth,
Air
Pollution
Evaluations
&
Solutions
Jana
Hutchins,
Arizona
State
University
2
°
Meteorology
°
Modeling
°
Air
Quality
Monitoring
Data
°
Receptor
Areas
°
Existing
and
Potential
Source
Areas
°
8­
Hour
Ozone
Boundary
Options
3
Data
Providers
°
Arizona
Department
of
Environmental
Quality
(
ADEQ)

°
Arizona
Land
Resource
Information
Systems
(
ALRIS)

°
Arizona
State
University
(
ASU)
 
Department
of
Mechanical
and
Aerospace
Engineering
­
Drs.
Fernando,

Grossman­
Clarke,
and
Lee
°
Gila
River
Indian
Community
°
Maricopa
County
°
Maricopa
Association
of
Governments
(
MAG)
Maps
Prepared
by:

ASU
­
GIS
Services,
Information
Technology
Jana
Hutchins,
Michael
Zoldak
and
Robert
Murray
°
Pinal
County
°
Salt
River
Project
°
Town
of
Payson
°
U.
S.
EPA
°
U.
S.
Geological
Survey
(
USGS)

°
University
of
Arizona
°
Yavapai
County
°
Air
Pollution
Evaluations
&
Solutions
­

Gary
Neuroth
°
Western
Regional
Air
Partnership
(
WRAP)
4
Meteorology
5
Wind
Sites
Source:
University
of
Arizona,
SRP,

Maricopa
County,
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS
6
Drainage
Winds
Source:
ADEQ,
Maricopa
County
Monitoring
sites
7
A.
M.
Transition
Winds
Source:
ADEQ,
Maricopa
County
Monitoring
sites
8
Upslope
Winds
Source:
ADEQ,
Maricopa
County
Monitoring
sites
9
Modeling
10
Highest
8hr
Ozone:
June
6th
HI
PV
SU
GL
SJN
MA
WPSS
NP
SP
CP
SC
TE
MC
CG
SCT
ME
PP
FH
BP
RV
CMB
AJ
CC
HU
QV
TO
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
20
25
30
35
40
45
Source:
ASU
Mechanical
and
Aerospace
Engineering
Department
11
Highest
8hr
Ozone:
July
12th
HI
PV
SU
GL
SJN
MA
WPSS
NP
SP
CP
SC
TE
MC
CG
SCT
ME
PP
FH
BP
RV
CMB
AJ
CC
HU
QV
TO
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
20
25
30
35
40
45
Source:
ASU
Mechanical
and
Aerospace
Engineering
Department
12
Air
Quality
Monitoring
Data
13
Ozone
Sites
Source:
Maricopa
County,
Pinal
County,

ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS
Annual
Fourth
Highest
8­
Hour
Ozone
Concentration
in
Parts
per
Billion
(
PPB)

Monitor
Site
Abbreviation
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Maricopa
County
Blue
Point
BP
83
89
87
87
80
86
Cave
Creek
CC
83
86
Central
Phoenix
CP
85
76
77
79
78
76
75
76
Falcon
Field
FF
81
83
82
75
81
84
Fountain
Hills
FH
88
86
86
85
83
86
Glendale
GL
80
72
76
70
81
81
78
83
Humboldt
Mountain
HM
81
90
86
82
85
90
Lake
Pleasant
LP
82
81
82
73
Maryvale
MA
78
86
77
80
73
84
Mesa
ME
92
90
84
80
83
75
74
72
Mt.
Ord
MO
84
88
87
90
77
North
Phoenix
NP
92
95
91
89
84
86
86
85
Palo
Verde
PAVE
71
77
80
80
80
74
78
Emergency
Management
EM
85
81
86
70
63
Super
Site
PXSS
87
79
79
76
79
76
Pinnacle
Peak
PP
91
91
82
86
83
86
85
84
Rio
Verde
RV
85
79
86
86
83
85
Roosevelt
RO
84
Salt
River
Pima
SRPI
92
92
82
87
82
South
Phoenix
SP
84
91
75
80
75
83
76
81
South
Scottsdale
SS
89
87
76
78
72
80
79
77
Surprise
SU
71
79
Tempe
TE
78
79
80
Vehicle
Emissions
VE
92
80
West
Chandler
WC
77
74
69
74
78
83
West
Phoenix
WP
84
81
78
86
91
81
75
84
Gila
County
Rye
RY
56
65
80
Tonto
N.
M.
TONO
87
Pinal
County
Apache
Junction
AJ
91
85
82
82
80
82
78
80
Casa
Grande
CG
71
79
72
68
78
75
74
78
Queen
Valley
QUAZ
79
83
Yavapai
County
Hillside
HISD
85
76
83
84
83
76
89
Values
in
blue
indicate
an
exceedance
of
the
8­
hour
ozone
standard
Three­
Year
Average
of
the
Annual
Fourth
Highest
8­
Hour
Ozone
Concentration
in
Parts
per
Billion
(
PPB)

Monitor
Site
Abbreviation
1995­
1997
1996­
1998
1997­
1999
1998­
2000
1999­
2001
2000­
2002
Maricopa
County
Blue
Point
BP
86
87
84
84
Cave
Creek
CC
Central
Phoenix
CP
79
77
78
77
76
75
Falcon
Field
FF
82
80
79
80
Fountain
Hills
FH
86
85
84
84
Glendale
GL
76
72
75
77
80
80
Humboldt
Mountain
HM
85
86
84
85
Lake
Pleasant
LP
81
78
Maryvale
MA
80
81
76
79
Mesa
ME
88
84
82
79
77
73
Mt.
Ord
MO
86
88
84
North
Phoenix
NP
92
91
88
86
85
85
Palo
Verde
PAVE
76
79
80
78
77
Emergency
Management
EM
84
79
73
Super
Site
PXSS
81
68
67
67
77
Pinnacle
Peak
PP
88
86
83
85
84
85
Rio
Verde
RV
83
83
85
84
Roosevelt
RO
Salt
River
Pima
SRPI
88
87
83
South
Phoenix
SP
83
82
76
74
80
South
Scottsdale
SS
84
80
75
76
77
78
Surprise
SU
75
Tempe
TE
79
Vehicle
Emissions
VE
West
Chandler
WC
73
72
79
West
Phoenix
WP
81
81
85
86
82
80
Gila
County
Rye
RY
67
Tonto
N.
M.
TONO
Pinal
County
Apache
Junction
AJ
86
83
81
81
80
80
Casa
Grande
CG
74
73
72
77
79
79
Queen
Valley
QUAZ
Yavapai
County
Hillside
HISD
81
81
83
81
82
Values
in
red
indicate
a
violation
of
the
8­
hour
ozone
standard
2003,
8­
Hour
Ozone
Standard
Exceedances
to
Date
in
Parts
per
Billion
(
PPB)

(
Preliminary
data
as
of
June
11,
2003)

Monitor
Site
Abbreviation
May
11
May
21
May
22
May
27
Maricopa
County
Blue
Point
BP
86
Cave
Creek
CC
87
88
Central
Phoenix
CP
Falcon
Field
FF
Fountain
Hills
FH
Glendale
GL
88
85
Humboldt
Mountain
HM
90
87
89
Lake
Pleasant
LP
Maryvale
MA
86
Mesa
ME
Mt.
Ord
MO
North
Phoenix
NP
88
Palo
Verde
PAVE
Emergency
Management
EM
Super
Site
PXSS
Pinnacle
Peak
PP
89
85
Rio
Verde
RV
Roosevelt
RO
Salt
River
Pima
SRPI
South
Phoenix
SP
South
Scottsdale
SS
85
Surprise
SU
Tempe
TE
Vehicle
Emissions
VE
West
Chandler
WC
West
Phoenix
WP
Gila
County
Rye
RY
Tonto
N.
M.
TONO
Pinal
County
Apache
Junction
AJ
Casa
Grande
CG
Queen
Valley
QUAZ
Yavapai
County
Hillside
HISD
17
Receptor
Areas
18
Study
Zones
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
19
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
20
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
21
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
22
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
23
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
24
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
25
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
26
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
27
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
28
Existing
and
Potential
Source
Areas
29
Smoke
Results
Sources:
ASU
Mechanical
and
Aerospace
Engineering
Department,

MAG
and
WRAP
30
Smoke
Results
Sources:
ASU
Mechanical
and
Aerospace
Engineering
Department,

MAG
and
WRAP
31
Source:
MAG,
ALRIS,
Pinal
County,

Yavapai
County,
Payson
32
Source:
MAG,
ALRIS,
Pinal
County
33
Source:
MAG,
ASU
Department
of
Mechanical
and
Aerospace
Engineering
34
Source:
MAG,
ALRIS,
Pinal
County,

Yavapai
County,
Payson,
Neuroth
35
Source:
MAG,
ALRIS,
Pinal
County,

Yavapai
County,
Payson,
Neuroth
36
Source:
MAG,
USGS,
ALRIS
37
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS
38
8­
Hour
Ozone
Boundary
Options
39
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
40
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
41
Source:
ADEQ,
USGS,
ALRIS,
Neuroth
