1
March
26,
2004
MEMORANDUM
TO:
EPA
Air
Docket
OAR­
2003­
0012
FROM:
William
Charmley
Engineer
Office
of
Transportation
and
Air
Quality
U.
S.
EPA
SUBJECT:
Summary
of
Meeting
with
the
Engine
Manufacturers
Association
and
the
California
Air
Resources
Board,
October
14,
2003
On
October
14,
2003,
representatives
from
EPA,
the
Engine
Manufacturers
Association
(
EMA),
and
the
California
Air
Resources
Board
(
CARB),
met
at
the
Westin
Hotel
inside
the
Detroit
Metropolitan
Airport
to
discuss
the
nonroad
diesel
Tier
4
proposal.
A
list
of
the
attendees
for
this
meeting
is
attached.

The
following
topics
were
discussed
during
the
meeting;

­
trailer
refrigeration
unit
test
cycle
­
crankcase
standards
and
measurement
options
­
add
on
values
for
in­
use
compliance
­
CO
standards
for
engines
<
11hp
and
engines
in
the
25­
50hp
range
­
HC
versus
NMHC
gaseous
emissions
measurement
­
emissions
deterioration
factor
testing
­
engine
installation
requirements
and
separate
shipment
of
engine
and
aftertreatment
­
defect
reporting
provisions
­
engine
labeling
provisions
­
use
of
good
engineering
judgement
in
the
regulations
­
treatment
of
confidential
business
information
in
the
certification
regulations
­
EPA
right­
of­
entry
into
engine
manufacturers
facilities
under
the
regulations
­
confirmatory
testing
­
regulations
applicable
to
engines
used
for
competition
­
transition
program
for
equipment
manufacturers
­
replacement
engine
regulatory
provisions
­
certification
test
engine
selection
criteria
­
definition
of
engine
power
for
determining
power
categories
under
Tier
4
attachments:
Attendees
List
Attachment:
Attendees
List
EPA
Meeting
with
Engine
Manufacturers
Association,
October
14,
2003
EMA
Member
Attendees:
Kevin
Korkada,
EMA
Rick
Bishop,
John
Deere
John
Duerr,
Detroit
Diesel
Corp.
Bill
Passie,
Caterpillar
Todd
Hendrickson,
Cummins
Inc.
Roy
Mann,
CNH
Cameron
Larson,
Kubota
Joe
Unseth,
Deutz
Christina
Lyons,
Isuzu
EPA
Attendees
Cle
Jackson,
Assessment
&
Standards
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
Don
Kopinski,
Assessment
&
Standards
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
Alan
Stout,
Assessment
&
Standards
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
Chuck
Moulis,
Assessment
&
Standards
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
Bill
Charmley,
Assessment
&
Standards
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
Jean­
Marie
Revelt,
Assessment
&
Standards
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
Rick
Gezelle,
Certification
and
Compliance
Division,
Office
of
Transportation
&
Air
Quality
George
Lawrence,
Office
of
Enforcement
and
Compliance
Assurance
by
phone
­
Steve
Silverman,
Office
of
General
Counsel
CARB
Attendees,
by
phone:
Jackie
Lourenco
